When planning a bathroom remodel, one of the most common decisions homeowners face is whether to install a walk-in shower, keep a bathtub, or try to include both. In Midwest homes like those in Milwaukee and across Wisconsin, the choice often comes down to lifestyle, space, and long-term functionality.

Both options have clear advantages—and the “right” choice depends on how you use your bathroom day to day.

Walk-In Showers: Modern, Accessible, and Low Maintenance

Walk-in showers have become one of the most requested features in bathroom remodels, especially in updated and aging-in-place designs.

Key benefits include:

• Easy accessibility with low or zero thresholds
• Modern, open look that makes bathrooms feel larger
• Easier cleaning with fewer hard-to-reach surfaces
• Customizable features like rainfall heads, benches, and niches

In many Midwest homes, walk-in showers are especially popular in primary bathrooms where convenience and daily use are top priorities.

They’re also a strong long-term investment, particularly for homeowners thinking about accessibility as they age in place.

Best for: Primary bathrooms, modern remodels, and homeowners prioritizing convenience and accessibility.

Bathtubs: Comfort, Families, and Relaxation

Bathtubs still hold strong appeal—especially for families and homeowners who value relaxation.

Key benefits include:

• Ideal for households with young children
• Great for soaking and relaxation
• Adds resale appeal in family-oriented homes
• Works well as a combination tub/shower in secondary bathrooms

In many Wisconsin homes, especially those with multiple bathrooms, a tub remains an important feature for practicality and resale value.

Even homeowners who prefer showers often keep at least one tub in the home for flexibility.

Best for: Family homes, secondary bathrooms, and resale-focused remodels.

What Midwest Homeowners Are Choosing Today

Trends in bathroom remodeling show a clear shift toward walk-in showers in primary suites—but not a complete elimination of tubs.

Common patterns include:

• Walk-in shower in the primary bathroom
• Tub/shower combo in secondary bathrooms
• Freestanding tubs in larger luxury remodels
• Converting unused tubs into larger shower spaces

In older Midwest homes, many remodels involve removing bulky built-in tubs to create more functional shower space.

Space, Layout, and Plumbing Considerations

Your home’s existing layout often plays a major role in the decision.

Things to consider:

• Available square footage in the bathroom
• Plumbing location and cost of relocation
• Ceiling height (for shower design options)
• Storage and layout efficiency

Walk-in showers often help open up smaller bathrooms, while tubs require more floor space and structural planning.

Resale Value: What Buyers Expect

If resale value is part of your decision, balance is key.

General market expectations:

• At least one bathtub in the home is still preferred by many buyers
• Primary bathroom walk-in showers are highly desirable
• Updated tile showers tend to increase perceived home value
• Outdated or unused tubs can sometimes reduce appeal

In Midwest markets, homes that offer both flexibility and updated finishes tend to perform best.

Maintenance and Long-Term Use

Another important factor is upkeep.

Walk-in showers:

• Easier daily cleaning
• Less risk of water damage with proper installation
• Fewer grout lines in modern designs (depending on tile choice)

Bathtubs:

• More surface area to clean
• Caulking and sealing require maintenance
• Can last decades with proper care

For many homeowners, maintenance simplicity is a major reason they switch to walk-in showers during remodels.

So… Which One Is Better?

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on how your household uses the space:

• Choose a walk-in shower if you want convenience, accessibility, and a modern feel
• Keep or include a tub if you have kids, enjoy soaking, or want to maximize resale flexibility
• Consider both if your layout and budget allow it

Final Thoughts

Bathroom remodels are all about balancing comfort, function, and long-term value. In many Midwest homes, the best solution isn’t choosing one over the other—it’s designing the bathroom around how you actually live.

A professional remodeler can help evaluate your space and recommend the best layout for your goals, whether that’s a spa-like walk-in shower, a family-friendly tub setup, or a combination of both.